Cleaning and Polishing Marble Surfaces with Baking Soda?

March 5, 2013 Off By Torin Dixon

By Torin Dixon
info@stonecareonline.com
The Dixons We hear often from people suggesting various home remedies for cleaning and polishing marble countertops and floors.

Some of the latest trends online is to “Polish Marble with Chalk” or Polish Marble with Baking Soda”. These ‘remedies’  are dubious at best, and can actually harm sensitive marble surfaces.

Here’s Why:

Chalk is actually mineral Talc. Talc is the softest of all minerals as listed on the Mohs Scale of Mineral Hardness. Talc is listed at harness “1”. Most marble used for building materials is in the hardness range of ‘4-6’, while some may be as soft as ‘3’.

When we polish marble in our shops or in the quarry factory, we use harder  abrasives than the surface we are polishing. The abrasive bricks are used in progressively finer and finer grits until a hard mineral ‘reflects light’, this is what makes a polished marble shine.

Most marble becomes dull either by foot traffic-abrasion, or by acids or other chemical cleaning products that actually etch the surface, causing microscopic pitting, making the marble less smooth, which manifests as appearing dull. By using talc or chalk alone, without smoothing out scratches and deeper abrasions, it would take hours and hours of polishing with talc to see any measurable difference in shine, because it is too soft.

Baking Soda is a basic with a pH of 9 which can dull sensitive marble surfaces with continuous use, as it is abrasive. See post on how Baking Soda can harm teeth (calcium based). If baking soda is bad for teeth, why do some suggest using it on marble, another calcium based stone?

Ammonia is very bad for marble as it has a pH of 11.6 and will burn (etch) polished marble surfaces.

Fortunately, there are commercial products available for restoring marble either using polishing waxes (for floors in good condition), or mild polishing pastes that finely smooth out marble and add waxes and conditioners to effect the shine of dull marble.

marble polishing cremeOne option is to use HMK P19 Marble and Granite Polish. By adding P19 to mop water and following up by gently buffing, this will add brilliance and shine to stone floors in good shape.

If your marble surface has scratches or deep wear then you may need to use a more abrasive polish like P21.

P21 Marble Polishing Paste

HMK P21 is a Professional Stone Care product from the world leader in Stone Care.

P21 is a polishing paste that can be used to polish out etch marks in marble, as long as they are not too deep. If you rub your finger over the etch mark and feel a soft depression or heavier texture, then you may need to gently smooth out area first with fine silicone carbide sandpaper (wet-dry) in 400 grit then 600 grit.

Wet sand area with a small sanding block in circular motions until smooth, then move to 600 grit and repeat. Apply P21 Marble Polish to a soft white cloth and apply in circular motion to area. Buff vigorously adding more polish if needed.

Immediately, use clean area of cloth to buff to a shine. If residual dulling remains, use more P21 Polishing paste and repeat buffing action.

For regular cleaning always use a pH neutral cleaner like HMK P24 Liquid Stone Soap. This maintenance cleaner will clean and condition with regular use, and not harm the surface like high pH cleaner can. Most dish soap is pH 11-14 to effectively clean dirty dishes and pans, but NOT good for marble surfaces.

These products can greatly enhance the look of moderately dull marble surfaces with regular use. If you need assistance with your stone, please contact Torin Dixon at 800-380-6881 or email at info@stonecareonline.com

CategoryCleaning Stone Restoring Stone Tip of The Week
Tagspolishing marble restoring shine to marble

About The Author

StoneCareOnline is owned by Torin and Diane Dixon who is are experts in natural stone importing, distribution, fabrication, installation and maintenance of all natural stone surfaces regardless of finish or texture. We are here to assist you in your StoneCare needs. Feel free to contact us at 800-380-6881

15 Comments

  • jen says:
    March 15, 2014 at 10:53 am

    Hi John,

    I’ve had white carrera countertops for about 1 1/2 yrs now. We cook multiple times a day on these counters and while I don’t notice any stains (yet) I do see a lot of water spots and some light etching. If I follow prior comments correctly, I should use P21 to fix up water spots and any light etching and use P24 for regular cleaning and then use P34 to reseal the counters? I’m I on the right track and am I missing anything for general maintenance?

    thanks,
    Jen

  • Michael says:
    September 20, 2013 at 8:52 pm

    Hey, great article. We use diamond pads (200 – 3000 grit) to polish marble that has been worn down, is the HMK p19 use for mainly maintenance purposes or can I use it with the diamond pads?

    Thanks

  • sharon hilaman says:
    September 16, 2013 at 1:24 pm

    hello, can you please tell me what to use on my mother”s head stone , india red marble,has no more shine,,,thank you for your time

  • Jerry Staden says:
    August 26, 2013 at 4:33 pm

    I have a culture marble bath room sink which is getting dull.
    What can I use to get the surface to shine again. This a manufactured product.

  • Amna says:
    July 12, 2013 at 11:06 pm

    Hi Torin,

    I recently made a very silly mistake and used vinegar to clean a new marble vanity. As you can imagine, the results are disturbing. The vinegar has left noticeable cloudy white “stains.” I was just about to use a baking soda and water paste to try to remedy the situation when I came across this article. Any suggestions? (This home is not in the US so it will be difficult for me to obtain any specific marble care products.)

    I hope your father is feeling much better.

    Thank you kindly,
    Amna

    • Torin Dixon says:
      July 14, 2013 at 8:05 pm

      Amna,
      As you may know, vinegar is an acid and will react with calcium based stone, dulling the polish and shine.
      You will need to have the marble refinished. It is recommended to use a professional marble fabricator to make repairs, as they use oxcylic acid to repolish the surface to a factory finish. If interested, please look for a local stone professional and obtain an estimate for this service.
      Best wishes,
      Torin

      • Joanne Mueller says:
        February 28, 2014 at 5:43 pm

        Hi Torin,

        Just to be clear, if I have a marble kitchen countertop that has obvious spots and rings caused by vinegar/citrus juice, does that mean a polishing paste won’t work and I’ll have to go straight to refinishing?

        Thanks for your help,
        Jo

        • Torin Dixon says:
          March 1, 2014 at 8:40 am

          Joanne, mild etching can be repaired using the P21, as it is much like a polishing compound. Deep etching may likely need resurfacing.

        • Torin Dixon says:
          April 18, 2014 at 5:20 am

          Jo,
          It is possible, if the etching is mild, that the P21 will work well enough to minimize the appearance of the etch marks. If this does not give you satisfactory results, then you would need to go to the next step. We always suggest the milder methods first.
          Best wishes,

          Torin Dixon

  • John says:
    May 8, 2013 at 8:26 am

    Hi Torin, great article. We are looking for guest articles / blog post for our two cleaning blogs. Please let me know if you are interested.

    Thanks, John

Comments are closed.